Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | vonneumannstan's commentslogin

>You cannot risk companies like Anthropic, OpenAI or their business partners like Microsoft having unfettered access to proprietary data on your company/businesses.

You do realize that businesses that have contracts with them can specify if they want their data used for training or not right?


Theres a reason those same mathematicians did not solve the problem on their own. Minimizing the impact the model made here seems unjustified.

If this were the case the problem would not have remained unsolved for this long. A new spell checker is not what cracked the problem.

This doesn't follow for me. There are what, Dozens or Erdos tier problems that got solved with no progress for decades? How does that factor in to your view?

IIUC the argument is that while unsolved there was much work done on them that shows up in the training data. The idea being that the LLM is limited to a small amount of inference over externally supplied data.

And yet the best humans could not use that same available data to solve the problems.

>People claiming dangers and risk are just pretending or posturing. I believe you are mentally ill.

>There's no more tangible risk than nuclear weapons, which we handled

Lol way to rewrite history. Nuclear armageddon is still a significant risk...


I am not rewriting. I am saying AI is not more dangerous in my opinion that Nuclear Weapons.

You are wrong. A teenager with enough GPUs could never dream of making a nuke but they are absolutely able to run capable AIs in their moms basement. Totally different class of danger

And do what with it ?

More and more complex and dangerous tasks every day.

Honestly I find these cavalier statements to be in incredibly poor taste. Unless you are completely blind it's obvious that AI is the most significant piece of technology invented since the Atomic Bomb and could very well be the most important thing ever built by Humans full stop. This kind of dismissive attitude is childish and will likely lead to incredibly bad outcomes for humanity.

Even if all that is true, why shouldn't people be able to joke about it? Your sentiment is borderline AI worship.

I don't think they were joking.

Sarcastic quips are basically the most human response to any new situation. Let us have fun

The atomic bomb destroyed cities and changed the face of war.

The launch video for Astra has 'can upload a photo to Ebay' as a highlight.


Yes, but precisely because it's capable of producing the economic equivalent of a nuclear explosion.

Please tell me that’s satire, it’s literally impossible to differentiate from actual AI boosters

You have blinders on. AI is becoming more dangerous by the day.

I’m on HN almost every day advocating for a complete ban of the technology because of its risks and externalities…

Then why are we arguing? I agree with you, I'm highlighting the fact that people making light of the technology is dangerous

I’m not the one arguing, I asked you if your comment was satire. I agree with the sibling comment, it reads like AI religious worshipping

Sorry the open sourcers cannot ever come to that believe as it sets up a conflict that cannot be resolved by their moral framework. Exactly like libertarians saying "just a little less regulation and we'll reach utopia".

The economy is already largely propped up by spending from the wealthiest decile.


>(SOMEHOW! I guess we forgot about Sora already)

Yes if theres one thing we know about Chips and AI its that the price of equivalent performance literally never decreases...


I think he's literally conceding your point by writing this essay. That there will be massive upheaval and yes maybe pitchforks if we don't get ahead of the problems.


nothing will happen. the '20s and '30s were much worse compared to today and nothing happened. Americans are much more complacent now than even then. People aspire to get rich, like on TikTok and "hustle culture," not to hang the rich.


Jevons Paradox says no. Even more "efficient" models will increase overall GPU demand and be good for NVIDIA.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: