This is a bad assumption on both ends (HN comments are most definitely not a bastion of free thought and expression.) but If people affected by PTSD can re-experience their trauma in controlled therapeutic settings using psychedelic compounds, so to can most others. Psychedelics are not for everyone, but they are certainly also not limited to chosen ones.
As a mini-side rant, I've found that people in the psychedelic community (defined as those that purposefully use psychedelics vs more spur of the moment usage) have pumped them selves up on their own identities as these "open minded explorers". I've actually found them to be belligerently dug in when faced with new evidence, information, and perspectives.
Source: I helped run a major city psychedelic community for a couple years
I honestly don't understand what happens to some people they trip. When I trip I get torn apart and question everything I believe in. After my first trip I thought wow if only everyone could experience this people would open their minds.
Then in time I met more and more people who regularly use psychs who were stuck in dogma. Recently I saw an interview with Dennis McKenna of all people who regularly trips (like his brother) and he just came across really disconnected like a dogmatic liberal like he was repeating what he had been told rather than thinking for himself.
It's been bothering me for a long time trying to understand it. I think the conclusion I have come to so far is that it opens your mind but only above whatever baseline you came from. The other thing is because the experiences have a feeling of being profound people who are not that open minded end up worshiping it and just fit themselves into that niche.
There's a long rant here, but it'll be pages worth of text. The short of it is that the so called leaders of the community are often accidental, untrained, uneducated, and largely unchecked. They say the right things and every one coalesces around them even if it's unsubstantiated gibberish (Terrance was the master of this and a total nut to be honest). It is very reminiscent of political dogma and zealotry (lets not pretend this is just a "dogmatic liberal" thing). Not to mention the big money they're pulling in from it now too (looking at you Bill Richards.)
There's no reason to continually trip, to take large doses, to try multiple psychedelics, etc. It's up to the individual to decide on what feels right for them. It is one of the most subjective and personal experiences you can have. Benchmarking against others is just...destructive really. No one in the community is saying that right now. It's just spiraling group think.
Yes essentially the leaders become like religious leaders. The problem is there is usually a kernel of truth to what they are saying which makes it easy to buy into if you're not thinking critically about it.
As a mini-side rant, I've found that people in the psychedelic community (defined as those that purposefully use psychedelics vs more spur of the moment usage) have pumped them selves up on their own identities as these "open minded explorers". I've actually found them to be belligerently dug in when faced with new evidence, information, and perspectives.
Source: I helped run a major city psychedelic community for a couple years