Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That is a horrible and illogical assumption to make. Stereotype threat is shown to exist for white males. There is a stereotype that white people are less athletic than black people. If you prime white males by reminding them of the stereotype that they cannot perform well athletically, they will do worse.

Source: pages 8-11, Whistling Vivaldi, by Stanford professor and stereotype threat researcher Claude Steele.

Stereotype threat has been shown to affect any group subjected to a negative stereotype. Steele's book is rife with examples. Stereotype threat can also be dispelled with enough encouragement and the right kind of mentorship. You can, for example, decrease the performance of Asian female math students by first reminding them of their gender, but then you can improve their performance, too, by reminding them of them being Asian.

I am appalled that you made the leap from "women experience stereotype threat" to "they are inferior and have universally inferior psyches" without considering "hmm, do other groups experience stereotype threat too?"



There is a stereotype that white people are less athletic than black people.

All else held equal, this would indeed make white men inferior athletes to black men, as I acknowledge in my response to danifong.

I didn't declare women as having "universally inferior psyches", I declared women as being potentially inferior in job-related tasks on the assumption that stereotype threat applies to those tasks in addition to GRE exams.


Yeah, sure, a group performs worse under discrimination; must be something wrong with them...


According to you, the simple non-discriminatory act of putting "Select one: Male [ ] Female [ ]" on a math test is sufficient to reduce female performance.

The value judgments ("something wrong with them") are something you fabricated, not something from my post.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: