Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> just liquidate it as soon as you receive it.

"just"

> It won't lose or gain 50% of its value in a matter of minutes.

If someone sets up a recurring payment of X bitcoin it means that on any given pay day your actual money is X*(absolutely random number). Minus the fees for converting to fiat.

> Also, note that you'd probably receive more donations if accepting crypto currencies

"Probably"



The fees for converting to fiat are generally _smaller_ than the fees MasterCard or Visa for instance will grab from credit card transactions [0][1]. If you are refering to the fees from the blockchain, note that L2 options exist, and not all cryptocurrencies have the absurd fees L1 ETHR would have, for instance Litecoin fees can be as small as 1 cent.

Relating to the varying amount monthly:

1 - It's a donation, not your source of income. If you really on that money that's your issue not of anyone else's.

2 - The platform such as Patreon could simply quote the value in dollars instead of BTC or whatever cryptocurrency. Recurring payments with crypto will have to be done manually anyways so this is a non-issue.

[0]: https://www.forbes.com/advisor/business/credit-card-processi...

[1]: https://help.coinbase.com/en/commerce/getting-started/fees


> It's a donation, not your source of income. If you really on that money that's your issue not of anyone else's.

We're literally in a topic about creators and Patreon where Patreon is a substantial source of income to quite a few creators.

And the dismissive tone about donations in general... well, I won't comment on that

> The platform such as Patreon could simply quote the value in dollars instead of BTC or whatever cryptocurrency.

Or they could just not bother.

> Recurring payments with crypto will have to be done manually anyways

Ah yes. The great digital system of the future where even such a simple thing as recurring payments must be done manually


   > And the dismissive tone about donations in general... well, I won't comment on that
Why not?

   > Or they could just not bother.
That's true. The creators have the option of creating their own cryptocurrency wallets and accepting the donations without any middleman. They could also choose a more libre alternative to Patreon such as OpenCollective [0][1] or Liberapay [2].

   > Ah yes. The great digital system of the future where even such a simple thing as recurring payments must be done manually 
I see that as a plus personally. Recurring payments are so hard to cancel at times with credit cards I'm at the point I create a new virtual credit card for every subscription I create. Theoretically you could also setup your wallet to automatically transact, it's just that's not a functionality of your cryptocurrency, just as recurring payments aren't a functionality of the dollar but rather of your bank/credit card provider.

[0]: https://opencollective.com/

[1]: https://docs.opencollective.foundation/how-it-works/financia...

[2]: https://en.liberapay.com/


> Why not?

Because a lot of people live or earn a lot of their living through donations, and quite a lot of opensource you're using would actually be helped with more donations.

> The creators have the option of creating their own cryptocurrency wallets and accepting the donations without any middleman

Except, you know, all the actual things that those "middlemen" do like provide verification that it is the actual artist and not a rip-off, provide hosting for their content etc.

> Recurring payments are so hard to cancel at times with credit cards I'm at the point I create a new virtual credit card for every subscription I create.

Yes, dark patterns around subscriptions are a problem. However, subscriptions and notifications about whether a person has canceled their subscirption or became a subscriber is valuable information to, you know, actually be able to plan ahead, and not wonder whether that person who did something manually yesterday will be there tomorrow.

Edit

> They could also choose a more libre alternative to Patreon such as OpenCollective [0][1] or Liberapay [2].

The could skip all the middlemen, or could chose these middlemen that I personally like and call them "libre" just because they accept cryptocurrency. And LiberaPay is literally a middleman with exactly zero additional value




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: