I'm just saying that his idea here should not be evaluated by a comparison to a group of people that he isn't even a member of. I do like the two axis chart though.
That's a fair assessment, and I also agree that we shouldn't be assigning people to either side of the aisle in discussions where it's not important. Alas, social security is a very political issue that has many people with strong feelings in either direction, so it is very hard to avoid seeming partisan.