I like the two axes idea, although "Rewatchability" would probably be better as "How much I liked it."
There are very high quality, well made movies that I don't like, and there are some really crappy ones that I do. And that's a good distinction to see in a review system.
Because sometimes you just want to watch a good shitty movie, but it's really difficult to tell the good shitty movies from the bad shitty movies when The Brady Bunch movie (brilliant) has the same rating as any Adam Sandler movie (awful).
Similarly, I've heard a proposal here on HN about having separate voting buttons for Agreement and Contributing. I might not agree with a comment, but admit it raises a good point. I might agree with another comment (or think it's funny) without it contributing to the current conversation.
There are very high quality, well made movies that I don't like, and there are some really crappy ones that I do. And that's a good distinction to see in a review system.
Because sometimes you just want to watch a good shitty movie, but it's really difficult to tell the good shitty movies from the bad shitty movies when The Brady Bunch movie (brilliant) has the same rating as any Adam Sandler movie (awful).