Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Don't write code that will re-display/re-post content of a Craigslist post on your 3rd party website.

The difference being it is it would be a Craigslist post I wrote and would contain photos I took. Those words came from my head, so are you saying Craigslist owns the copyright to them as soon as I submit the ad and thus I cannot post that content elsewhere?

As the article said, Krrb is not scraping or even visiting Craigslist. The data gets to Krrb on the volition of the user who posted to Craigslist.



> The data gets to Krrb on the volition of the user who posted to Craigslist.

How does Krrb verify this? How does Krrb ensure that it's the post's author, and not some random bot hitting executing their javascript in an effort to scam users?

> Craigslist owns the copyright to them as soon as I submit the ad and thus I cannot post that content elsewhere?

You absolutely have that right. It's your data, you can re-post it wherever you like. However, Krrb does not have the right to scrape data from Craigslist, on your say-so.

The content was posted to Craigslist with a license for Craigslist to publish it, not for Krrb. Much like a book author gives up certain rights to distribute a book through a publisher (including where and when it's published), the user is giving up certain rights to post the content on Craigslist. Whether this is a bad thing or not is up to the author of the content, not a 3rd party to decide.


-> "Krrb does not have the right to scrape data from Craigslist, on your say-so." Wrong logic here my friend, it is the user to scrape and repost. Krrb just help user to make the process easier by making the tool




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: