I think they've done a decent job of showing how well it holds devices, BUT, I think they'll have a difficult time really getting us to believe how secure it is until we can actually feel it on a bike. If they can get these into shops and have people actually touch it, I suspect it would have a huge impact on the naysayers (like yourself).

I think I agree, but I will use it to hold my older phone, which still serves perfectly well as a Strava / Maps (offline) / GPS device for getting around. I'm sure that I am not the only person on HN who has a 2 year old smartphone gathering dust somewhere.

This might just be me, but if you have a perfectly good two year old phone. Why did you buy a new one?

I recently bought another battery for my Galaxy S2 because the old one died. I have no plans for replacing that phone until I absolutely have to. Preferably not until there is a Samsung Galaxy S6 or so.

Hehe, I still use my Galaxy S (one), which appears to be indestructible. Several falls on concrete did not kill the phone. Also, the battery is cheap to replace, so I always have an old backup battery with me. But most important, it's rooted and runs Android 4.2. Yeah, it's a little slow, but upgrading wouldn't change all too much. 400 USD for a little more speed on the same functionality? Naah ... All my previous phones like ridiculously old by now, but even the most recent devices only differ in detail from my good old Samsung ;)

Yeah that is pretty much what is keeping me from upgrading.

My S2 is still fast enough to run anything I've tried.

What would I get by buying a S4? A bigger screen, 4G access and NFC? Other then that I am not really aware of any benefits. I run CM nightly anyway so in terms of software it's as good as the new phones, and I only ended up running custom firmware because Samsung stopped doing updates.

Really it's not in "perfectly good" condition. Broken screen, broken usb connector, bad battery life, water damage that causes the cell radio to intermittently not work.

But it still works as my bike-phone.

Ah, I understand then. I just do not understand the people buying a new phone every time there is a new model.

I can understand wanting the software upgrade, but in terms of hardware I do not think it's worth upgrading all the time.

Some people like new things

I have several, but I didn't know Androids had offline Maps capability. Also, is it possible to use GPS without an active cellphone account with a carrier?

You can tell google maps to save a set of directions for offline use. Same with scout which is the free app from telenav that all sprint customers get.

> Also, is it possible to use GPS without an active cellphone account with a carrier?

I can use GPS in airplane mode, so I suppose it works.

Hi there! Thanks for the feedback, I work for BikeCityGuide and I can tell you that we eat our own dog food, we put our own smartphones daily in there and have had no issues whatsoever until now!

We really designed it to be very sturdy :)