Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How does turning something into a commodity that people buy, sell, and trade for profit raise prices?


It creates additional demand because the house not only provides shelter, but also takes on the form of an investment. How many people do you know who talk themselves into buying a house because of the potential pay off when prices rise?


I have heard that people do that, but I know zero people who have done it.


My dad tried. Lost a bunch of money.


It gets worse when foreign real estate speculation is allowed. Where I live most new condo developments are bought out by millionaires in Asia for the sole purpose of making money thus I need $700,000 for a tiny studio.


Supply and demand? Increase demand, supply is largely fixed* , prices go up.

* a house in the boonies isn't really a substitute for a house in the city. Every house has demand from people who want to buy it as a home plus the demand of people who want to buy it to rent/flip/scrape it.


You are confusing land and housing - they are not the same. Land area is fixed but habitable space is not. In built up areas the constraint on building new housing is largely regulatory (mostly planning regulations).


I lump land and housing together because that's how reality does it. Aside from trailer-houses they all stay on one piece of land for the duration.

If an analysis depends on houses being able to fluidly change land positions I don't think it would be very useful.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: